Unreported Income - IRS Civil Tax Fraud and Criminal Tax Evasion
The IRS will often pursue a Taxpayer first, on criminal tax evasion, and then, civil tax fraud (otherwise, the taxpayer could assert, during the civil investigation, his Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination). If the IRS pursues civil tax fraud first and wins, they may collect civil penalties, tax and obtain discovery information, and then pursue criminal proceedings (and use the civil file to prosecute).
Civil Tax Fraud, and Criminal Tax Evasion cases have different:
I. Burdens of Proof
II. Statutes of Limitations (Unreported Income)
III. Penalties
IV. Collateral Estoppel (Civil/Criminal Issues)
I. Burdens of Proof (Evidentiary Standard)
a. Civil Tax Fraud: "Clear and Convincing Evidence" (a.k.a. Preponderance of the Evidence)
b. Criminal Tax Evasion: "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt" (Higher Standard)
II. Statutes of Limitations
a. Civil Tax Fraud: No statute of limitations (tax can be assessed at any time).
b. Criminal Tax Fraud (Evasion): The criminal statute of limitations is only on the prosecution of the crime i.e. tax evasion (not the assessment of tax owed).
Generally, 3 years after the offense is committed.
Six (6) years for specified offenses (including: unreported income) (IRC 6531)
Under Federal Criminal Code (Title 18 U.S.C.A.) 5 years after the commission of a crime.
The statute begins to run when the last of the acts constituting the tax evasion is committed.
III. Penalties (Unreported Income)
(a) Civil Tax Fraud
(1) Fraudulent Failure to File Tax Return (IRC 6651(f))
15% of net amount of tax due for each month, (up to a maximum of 5 months), for a maximum penalty of 75% (of unpaid tax) (IRC 6651(f)). This is the only penalty imposed for failure to file.
(2) Fraudulent Tax Return (Unreported Income) (IRC 6663(d))
If any part of an underpayment of tax (required to be shown on a tax return) is due to fraud, a penalty equal to 75% of the portion of the underpayment.
(3) Accuracy - Related Penalty (IRC 6662(b)(1)-(5))
A penalty at a flat rate of 20% on portion of underpayment of tax. The fraud penalty and accuracy-related penalty apply only for filed tax returns.
(4) Spousal Liability (IRC 6663(c))
For a joint tax return, both spouses are subject to joint and several liability for the entire tax liability. The civil fraud penalty applies only to the spouse responsible for the underpayment that is attributable to fraud.
(5) Failure to Pay Tax The penalty applies to the amount of unpaid tax due:
Unpaid tax shown as due on a tax return (IRC 6651(a)(2))
percent (of unpaid tax) for each month, up to a maximum of 25% (of unpaid tax)
Unpaid tax not shown as due on a return (i.e., unreported income (IRC 6651(a)(3))
percent (of unpaid tax) for each month up to a maximum of 25% (of unpaid tax)
OFFSETTING PENALTIES (IRC 6651(c)(1))
If taxpayer is liable for more than one of the delinquency penalties with respect to any tax return, the amount of the penalty for failure to file, is reduced by the amount of the penalty for failure to pay (the amount shown on a return for any month for which both penalties apply )
There is no offset for the penalty for failure to pay tax (IRC 6651(a)(3)) not shown as due on a return (i.e., unreported income).
No credit is allowed against the civil fraud penalty for any criminal fines paid for income tax evasion and conspiracy to defraud the U.S.
(b) Criminal Tax Evasion (Unreported Income) (1) IRC 7201:
Criminal penalty for willful attempt by any person to evade or defeat any tax or the payment of any tax.
Conviction, punishable:
Fine: $100,000 (individual) $500,000 (corporation)
Imprisonment: Not more than 5 years (or both fine and imprisonment)
(2) IRC 7203: Criminal Failure to File or Pay Taxes
Willful failure to pay tax, file a return, keep required records, or supply required information
Fine: $25,000 (individual) $100,000 (corporation)
Imprisonment: Up to one year (or both fine and imprisonment)
IV. Collateral Estoppel:
When criminal proceedings are followed by civil proceedings, the legal doctrine of collateral estoppel may apply. This doctrine provides that an issue necessarily decided in a previous proceeding (the 1st proceeding) will determine the issue in a subsequent proceeding (the 2nd proceeding), but only as to matters in the 2nd proceeding that were actually presented and determined in the 1st proceeding.
a. Conviction for criminal tax evasion collaterally estops the taxpayer from contesting the existence of fraud for purposes of the civil fraud penalty because a finding of criminal fraud (beyond a reasonable doubt) establishes proof of civil fraud (by clear and convincing evidence).
b. Acquittal of criminal tax evasion does not collaterally stop the government from proving civil fraud (by clear and convincing evidence). The acquittal established that proof of fraud did not exist beyond reasonable doubt, but that does not mean that proof of fraud by clear and convincing evidence does not exist.
Gary S. Wolfe, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATION
9100 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 530 East Beverly Hills, CA, 90212
Tel: 310-274-8847 Fax: 310-274-3118
email: gsw@gswlaw.com
Gary S. Wolfe, Esq. International Tax Practice offers the following legal expertise: IRS Tax Audits, International Asset Protection & International Litigation. Please see http://www.gswlaw.com for more info
Tax Fraud Attorneys
Tax fraud is a white collar crime involving offenses like tax evasion, non filing of tax returns, non declaration of income a...
Unreported Income (IRS) - Criminal Penalties - Tax Preparers
Clients, with unreported income, may subject tax preparers to criminal penalties, fines, costs of prosecution and up to 10 ye...
Tax Fraud Lawyers
Some individuals and organizations do not follow the standard procedure of paying their share of taxes to the government. By ...
Tax Attorneys
Tax attorneys are legal professionals who advise people in terms of tax planning and represent clients in cases of tax disput...
Earnings From Abroad and Taxes
With the every expanding global economy, many people receive earnings from foreign entities. Unfortunately, the federal gover...
How to Avoid Offshore Tax Evasion - A 3 Step Test
Offshore tax evasion is crime in several onshore countries and includes jail time so it should be avoided. On the other hand...
What Is It Good For?
What is tax? Tax is not voluntary, and everyone says tell me about it! But thats kind of its definition, its an involuntary p...
Tax Attorney Jobs
Tax attorney jobs are available in the fields of business, income, property, estate, and international taxes. Apart from a pr...
International Tax Attorneys
Taxes must be paid on the basis not just of income earned within the country, but also outside the national borders. The IRS ...
Render Unto Caesar
Once a year Canadian taxpayers are required, by law, to file an income tax return in the prescribed form: $150(1).For individ...
How Can You Avoid Mortgage Fraud?
Fraud is a growing crime in America. From mortgage fraud to identity theft, consumers are at a daily risk of becoming victims...
Trust, Tax Morale and Corruption
It is often argued that tax evasion is widespread. The problem is that a high level of tax evasion reduces governments abilit...
2006 List of Tax Scams Released by IRS
Every year, the IRS issues a list of tax scams. The goal is to alert taxpayers to the lack of merit of certain strategies as ...
Progressive Taxation
Progressive taxation is defined as a form of tax that charges a bigger percentage rate on the income of high income group tha...
Federal Tax Returns
Congress first imposed the first federal income tax in 1862 to raise money for the Union in the Civil War. A 3% tax was fixed...
Practical Tips For Avoiding an IRS Audit
There is not foolproof method of avoiding an IRS audit. It is also not very sensible to not claim the deductions that you are...
Internal Revenue Service Audits
Pick your favorite scary movie. It could be the first Alien or something else. No matter how scary they were, nothing is scar...
Los Angeles Tax Law Explained
The tax laws differ from state to state. The Los Angeles tax laws are particularly complicated and are enough to baffle anyon...
Reporting Foreign Financial Accounts
If you are a US citizen, it is important to know that you must report the presence of any foreign financial accounts you have...
Coffee in America
American coffee? Technically there is no such thing, at least none that is grown in North America. There is such a thing as t...